THE STATS: Fernando Alonso vs Jenson Button

It is the end of the 2014 season and attention already falls on next year’s incumbent and how the grid may take shape. The formula and characteristics needed to maintain a drive in Formula 1 is becoming more and more complex by the season as money, technical changes and a the birth of Mercedes dominance marks the start of a new era.

The rumour mill is spinning out of control and the obligatory bluffing has begun. The circus started with Sebastian Vettel and his decision to leave Red Bull after more than fifteen years under their guidance and with four world championships to his name. He will partner Kimi Raikkonen at an ailing Ferrari but where does this leave Fernando Alonso and the man he has been tipped to replace, McLaren’s Jenson Button?

For now, it is mere speculation and all attempts to ask Ron Dennis end with a response that neither confirms nor denies any rumours. It is of course possible that both drivers will lead the new McLaren-Honda age into its first year but for the sake of argument, here is a comparison between two of the most respected drivers on the grid. Well, arguably anyway.

Jenson Button made his F1 début at the Australian Grand Prix in 2000 with his Spanish rival joining the grid exactly one year later for Minardi. Most recently, Max Verstappen’s relative inexperience has been compared to that of Button – the Briton joined F1 after only two years out of karts. However, it is in fact Alonso who contested fewer junior championships before his first grand prix start. Alonso is the fourth youngest driver in history to start a race (as of November 2014) while Button rests at joint ninth.

Button secured his first win at the 2006 Hungarian Grand Prix at his 113th race, starting from fourteenth to storm through the field. Alonso first stood atop the podium at the same circuit in 2003 eighteen months after his début in what was his second season with Renault. The Spaniard’s 2014 team mate Raikkonen is the only other driver from the 2003 Hungarian Grand Prix to have contested the most recent season.

Between them, they can boast (not that they would) three world championships – Alonso’s coming from his time at Renault in 2005 and 2006 when Michael Schumacher’s reign of dominance came to an end. Button’s title came in 2009 when Brawn grew from the ashes of an ailing Honda. His extra season in F1 over Alonso ensured Button was the most experienced driver on the 2014 grid with 266 starts by the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix. In contrast, Alonso has contested 235 throughout his fourteen year career.

The table below depicts more statistics for easy comparison. The final three columns depict the driver’s position in the championship at the end of the season.

*The drivers’ initials are listed alphabetically. This order is not intended to reflect any bias. No conclusion has been drawn from the data – instead you are invited to form your own opinion based on the evidence shown above.

Starts Points Wins Podiums Poles 2012 2013 2014
ALO 235 1767 32 97 22 2nd 2nd 6th
BUT 266 1198 15 50 8 5th 9th 8th

FERNANDO ALONSO1280px-Fernando_Alonso_2013_Malaysia_FP1
Age: 33
Debut: 2001 Australian Grand Prix (12th place)
Team(s): 4 (Minardi, Renault, McLaren, Renault, Ferrari)
Championships: 2 (2005, 2006)
2014 team: Ferrari

Mclaren_MP4-29_Jenson_Button_2014_F1_Chinese_GPJENSON BUTTON
Age: 34
2000 Australian Grand Prix (RET)
6 (Williams, Benetton, Renault, BAR Honda, Brawn, McLaren)
1 (2009)
2014 team: McLaren

One thought on “THE STATS: Fernando Alonso vs Jenson Button

  1. Hi Katie, nice insights. However, if their names would have been blanked out for non-F1 audience and they had to make a choice as to who they want to pick, it would be Alonso by light years. Button is good but no where as good as Alonso. To settle this matter on the track, I believe it would be good to see them both racing for McLaren. Will McLaren and Honda make that choice, keeping in mind what happened in 2007?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s